founded 2004 by ron cruger
A place for intelligent writers
by Jon Burras
A place for intelligent readers
2016 Spectator Ron - The Spectator All Rights Reserved
Your comments about this column are welcome ~ e-mail Jon at
The Save a Tree and Go Paperless Myth
You might have lived your life with unbridled enthusiasm for environmental issues
and social justice campaigns. You are the first to support a cause and often recruit friends and family onboard to cheer on your mission.
Everyone looks at you as a warrior/activist and you feel immensely proud of your actions. Over the course of your activist life you
have been involved in many campaigns and have rallied for many factions.
many who speed off into politically correct marches and campaigns do so with an abundance of enthusiasm but very little forward thinking.
Their zeal and energy might drive them while their rational thought and their down-line analysis remains stunted. Many of today's
protests and campaigns run only on emotional momentum with very little substance to back them up. Such is the case of the recent campaign
to "save trees by going paperless" initiative. While often well-intentioned, most of the people who participate in this endeavor have
not thought through clearly the consequences of their actions and have very little facts to back up their strong idealism.
years ago a campaign started that anointed technology as the great savior for our world and our environment. The concept arose that
if we could switch our lives over from a physical and analog world into a pure digital world that we would be light years ahead in
our evolution. This revolutionary idea swept through our world and has permeated nearly every aspect of our lives, from travel reservations
to banking and from communication to business. The idea that technology will save us has been the backbone of this idea.
The "go paperless campaign" relies heavily on the emotional and pseudo-spiritual shaming of anyone caught cutting down a tree or using
lumber or paper products. It is commonly believed that those living in a digital life are somewhat more aware and more connected to
the Earth. Guilt and shaming are common bullying strategies used to stop people from using paper and wood products. The killing of
a tree is often equated with animal rights activists protesting against mink coats or Greenpeace protesting against Japanese whaling
fleets killing whales so that patrons in Japanese sushi restaurants can enjoy eating fine whale meat.
How well is that working out? Most would agree that it is not working out very well. The digital age has eroded much of our lives
and brought us to the edge of near-extinction level events. Hackers are stealing credit cards at record levels, along with government
records and secrets, corporate files and communications as well as the vital information and identities of the ordinary citizen. Endless
waves of passwords, encrypted files, government countermeasures, off site and remote back up systems have not rescued the misguided
technology revolution. The famous "I-Cloud" system is not even safe and secure. Businesses, corporations and nations are standing
on a fragile edge just waiting for the next cyber attack. Government military plans have been stolen by rogue hackers. How long will
it be before a cyber attack sets off a nuclear weapon, destroys a dam or wipes out an entire electrical power grid?
The same can be said about the "save a tree and go paperless" campaign. Converting our entire society to a digital structure is a
very ill-conceived endeavor. Going paperless is just one more layer of this movement to live in a digital age. This campaign is very
misguided, based on little facts and is actually very harmful to our society.
the facts. The United States has a very well-managed forestry system. Most trees harvested these days do not come from ancient old-growth
forests but are planted for the sole purpose of harvesting them to be used in paper products, lumber and other wood-based commodities.
The United States has a system in place that for every one tree cut down another two trees are planted. In the northern part of the
country from Minnesota all the way to Maine there has been a 28% increase in the forest in the last fifty years. In fact, U.S. forestland
across the country in the last fifty years has increased by 49% in spite of a thriving logging industry. We have an abundance of renewable
wood resources for our paper and lumber products. This is unlike some other regions of the world where cutting down trees is occurring
much faster than any replanting of those trees.
Lumber is a renewable product when the
forests are well managed like in the United States. Imagine if farmers planted food crops but were not allowed to sell those products
to people to eat. A sustainable forest system is not unlike an organic farm where the product renews itself each year.
The save a tree campaign and go paperless was most likely started by large corporations masquerading as grass-roots movements. Every
time you go digital and stop putting your records on real paper or making a digital bank deposit instead of writing a check you are
putting someone out of work. People are paid to grow trees, harvest trees, transport trees to mills, create lumber and paper products,
market and sell those products, print and design paper goods, open envelopes and make paper check deposits. Unknowingly you are putting
people out of work in an up line that is many layers removed. The digital economy is no different than self-scanning checkout lines
in super markets and robots in factories. The digital economy and go paperless idealism is a way for corporations to eliminate jobs.
Many people are becomingly overly suspicious of the go paperless campaign and are beginning
to see the true motivation behind this cause. In one survey from Twosidesna.org nearly 80% of those questioned were skeptical about
the real reason that corporations were encouraging their customers and employees to go paperless. Most felt that there was some ulterior
motive in play.
A digital economy has created a surge in the need for electricity to power
all of those laptops, desktops, cell phones, ATM machines, tablets and gadgets. Most of the electricity produced in the United States
(84%) still comes from fossil fuels (oil, coal and natural gas). By participating in a digital economy with all of your electrical
devices you are actually making the environment even worse as the demand for electricity has skyrocketed. Look no further than how
many devices you currently have plugged into your home or office wall outlets and you will discover that most likely you do not have
enough electrical plugs to handle it all.
As global warming looms over us from hydro-carbons
blasted into the air by cars, factories and power plants, the use of your computer or cell phone has only added more strain on the
environment, much more than by harvesting renewable trees. Up to 600 square miles in West Virginia, Kentucky and North Carolina have
been deforested and stripped clean in order to harvest the coal used to burn in many of the nation's power plants. This deforestation
of land is in order to provide for you the power to charge your cell phone and lap top computer. Electrical consumption is far more
damaging to the environment than harvesting renewable trees.
In addition, there is a vast
amount of resources now required to build those electrical gadgets. Precious metals like gold, copper, cobalt, lead, nickel, cadmium,
and mercury must be dug from the Earth, often in remote and fragile ecosystems on the planet. Lithium ion battery factories are needed
in record numbers to supply much of our vast battery needs. These factories require enormous resources and power to operate them.
You are creating far more damage to the Earth in constructing a computer or cell phone than harvesting renewable trees.
Paper products made from trees are not going to waste. In 2015 the United States recycled about sixty-seven percent of all paper and
reused this natural material to produce other products. This recycled paper was reconstituted into products like paper towels, newsprint
and computer paper. In addition, the remaining paper that is not recycled might end up in a land fill and as it breaks down it will
create methane gas that is captured and used as a fuel. Nature does not waste anything and has its own recycling program. Thousands
of jobs are at stake and those jobs would disappear if we were not using paper products. More than 450,000 jobs are produced in the
entire recycling industry (paper, electronics, glass, plastic etc.).
In today's age with
a plethora of media sources, from mainstream media to social media, we are bombarded by many false narratives that gain momentum without
any real facts or substance behind them. Is it not time to dismantle the go paperless and save a tree campaign? Should we not examine
this notion that going digital is actual benefitting us?
Make sure that you say hello to your
postal delivery person each day because he may lose his job soon because there are not enough paper letters and envelopes to deliver.
Sit down and write an actual letter to someone, place a stamp on it and put in it the mail box. Pay your bills with a real check and
envelope rather than an e-bill account. Do your own homework and research before you allow your emotions to lead you down an errant
path. Question the true intent of corporations. If you work in the mail room or in the marketing department it might be your job that
the company is trying to get rid of by going paperless.
The save a tree and go
paperless campaign might seem warm and fuzzy but it is very misguided and as many people suspect, a secretive collusion by corporations
to eliminate jobs. Energy consumption is reaching critical output each year in large part due to a digital economy. If you really
want to help the environment then limit your use of technology and use more paper products. Land is being clear-cut and the trees
removed in this country to harvest the coal, oil and natural gas beneath it to produce electricity so that you can check your social
media account every ten minutes. After all, it might be your job that is cut next and after your cell phone's battery fails renewable
and recyclable trees will still be growing strong.